AMD Athlon Silver 3050U vs Intel Core i5-4288U Comparison
AMD Athlon Silver 3050U
Core i5-4288U
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon Silver 3050U vs Intel Core i5-4288U
The Intel Core i5-4288U and AMD Athlon Silver 3050U are both dual-core mobile processors, yet the benchmark data reveals they are optimized for entirely different workloads. The AMD chip wins the majority of head-to-head tests, securing 5 wins against the Intel’s 2, but the nature of those victories tells a more complex story. The Intel part’s wins are massive in magnitude, while the AMD’s are consistent but narrow, suggesting the choice between them hinges on whether a user prioritizes raw multi-threaded rendering or specific legacy application performance.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The most striking result is in Geekbench multicore, where the Intel Core i5-4288U posts a score of 1745 against the AMD Athlon Silver 3050U’s 1309. This translates to a 33.3% lead for Intel, the largest delta in the entire comparison. This is a decisive victory, indicating that in this particular benchmark, the older Haswell architecture with its 2.60 GHz base clock and 3.10 GHz boost clock significantly outperforms the newer Zen-based chip. The single-core Geekbench test also favors Intel, with a score of 896 versus 803, an 11.6% advantage. This suggests Intel’s architecture holds a clear edge in certain integer and floating-point operations that Geekbench emphasizes.
However, the Cinebench suite tells the opposite story. Across all four Cinebench tests, the AMD Athlon Silver 3050U wins by a remarkably consistent margin of approximately 10.7% to 10.8%. In Cinebench R23 multicore, AMD scores 2505 versus Intel’s 2237, a 10.7% advantage. The single-core R23 test shows a similar pattern, with AMD at 353 and Intel at 315, a 10.8% gap. This consistency is notable; it suggests that the AMD chip’s architectural efficiency in rendering workloads is uniform across different core counts and test versions. The Cinebench R20 multicore results are equally telling: AMD’s 1052 beats Intel’s 939, and the R15 multicore test shows AMD winning 252 to 225. The AMD processor’s advantage in Cinebench is not a fluke of one test version but a systemic performance characteristic.
The data shows a clear split: Intel wins decisively in Geekbench, while AMD wins consistently in Cinebench. The average benchmark scores reflect this near-parity, with Intel at 927 and AMD at 917, a negligible difference of about 1%. This average obscures the significant swings in individual tests. The Intel part’s 33.3% Geekbench win is a massive outlier, but the AMD’s five smaller wins across the Cinebench suite are enough to make the average scores nearly identical. The percentile rankings also reinforce this: Intel sits at the 25th percentile of all CPUs, while AMD is at the 24th, placing them in essentially the same performance tier despite their divergent benchmark profiles.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Athlon Silver 3050U is the clear winner for any workload that relies on Cinebench’s rendering engine. This includes tasks like 3D modeling, animation, and video rendering, where the consistent ~10.7% performance lead would translate to shorter render times. The AMD chip’s higher 3.20 GHz boost clock and larger 4 MB shared L3 cache likely contribute to this advantage. The data suggests that for creative professionals or students running rendering tasks, the AMD processor is the more capable choice.
The Intel Core i5-4288U, conversely, wins decisively in Geekbench, which is a more general-purpose benchmark covering everything from encryption to image processing. The 33.3% multicore and 11.6% single-core leads are substantial, meaning the Intel chip would likely feel snappier in everyday applications like web browsing, office productivity, and photo editing. The Intel part’s 2.60 GHz base clock is higher than AMD’s 2.20 GHz, which may explain its advantage in workloads that are less dependent on boost clocks and more on sustained performance. For a user who prioritizes general system responsiveness over specific rendering tasks, the Intel chip’s benchmark profile is more favorable.
Another way to look at the split is via the nearest rivals. The Intel i5-4288U’s closest competitor is the Intel Core i7-4600U, with a deltaPct of -0.5%, meaning the i5-4288U is slightly slower. The AMD Athlon Silver 3050U’s closest rival is the AMD Ryzen Embedded R1305G, with a deltaPct of -0.2%. These rival relationships show that both chips are positioned in the same performance neighborhood, but their specific strengths and weaknesses are distinct. The Intel chip is more aligned with older high-end mobile parts, while the AMD chip is closer to embedded Ryzen parts, highlighting its Zen architecture lineage.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has a higher average benchmark score?
A: The Intel Core i5-4288U has an average benchmark score of 927, while the AMD Athlon Silver 3050U has a score of 917. The difference is roughly 1%, making them statistically similar overall.
Q: In which benchmark does the Intel Core i5-4288U have its biggest win?
A: The Intel Core i5-4288U’s biggest win is in Geekbench multicore, where it scores 1745 against the AMD’s 1309, a 33.3% advantage. This is the largest performance delta in the entire head-to-head comparison.
Q: How consistent is the AMD Athlon Silver 3050U’s performance in Cinebench?
A: The AMD Athlon Silver 3050U wins all four Cinebench tests by a remarkably consistent margin, with deltaPct values ranging from -10.7% to -10.8%. This uniformity suggests a stable architectural advantage in rendering workloads.
Q: What do the percentile rankings indicate about these two chips?
A: The Intel Core i5-4288U is at the 25th percentile of all CPUs, while the AMD Athlon Silver 3050U is at the 24th. This places them in the same performance tier, despite their divergent results in specific benchmarks.
Q: Which chip has a higher boost clock speed?
A: The AMD Athlon Silver 3050U has a boost clock of 3.20 GHz, which is higher than the Intel Core i5-4288U’s 3.10 GHz. However, the Intel chip has a higher base clock of 2.60 GHz compared to the AMD’s 2.20 GHz.
Q: Are there any benchmarks where the AMD chip loses to the Intel chip?
A: Yes, the AMD Athlon Silver 3050U loses to the Intel Core i5-4288U in both Geekbench multicore and single-core tests. In the multicore test, AMD trails by 33.3%, and in single-core, it trails by 11.6%.
Specification Differences
The two processors differ in several key specifications. The Intel Core i5-4288U has a base clock of 2.60 GHz and a boost clock of 3.10 GHz, while the AMD Athlon Silver 3050U has a base clock of 2.20 GHz and a boost clock of 3.20 GHz. The AMD chip has a higher boost clock by 0.10 GHz, but the Intel chip has a higher base clock by 0.40 GHz. The TDP also differs, with the Intel part rated at 28 W and the AMD part at 15 W, indicating the AMD chip is designed for lower power consumption. The sockets are different: Intel uses BGA 1168, while AMD uses Socket FP5. The memory support also varies, with the Intel chip supporting DDR3 and the AMD chip supporting DDR4. The AMD chip has a dual-channel memory bus and a specified memory bandwidth of 38.4 GB/s, while the Intel chip’s memory bus and bandwidth are not listed.
Architecture Differences
The architectural divide is substantial. The Intel Core i5-4288U is built on the Haswell architecture, using a 22 nm process node manufactured by Intel, with 1,400 million transistors on a 118 mm² die. The AMD Athlon Silver 3050U is based on the Zen architecture, codenamed Dali, using a 14 nm process node from GlobalFoundries, with 3,500 million transistors on a 148 mm² die. The AMD chip has more than double the transistor count on a larger die, reflecting its newer design. Cache configurations also differ. The Intel chip has 64 KB of L1 and 256 KB of L2 per core, with 3 MB of shared L3 cache. The AMD chip has 96 KB of L1 and 512 KB of L2 per core, with 4 MB of shared L3 cache. The AMD part’s larger cache hierarchy is a significant architectural advantage. The integrated graphics also differ: Intel uses HD 5100, while AMD uses Radeon Vega 3. The AMD chip supports PCIe Gen 3 with 8 lanes (CPU only), while the Intel chip’s PCIe configuration is not listed. The release dates are far apart, with Intel launching on June 3, 2013, and AMD on January 5, 2020.
The Verdict
The data presents a clear, albeit unconventional, verdict. The AMD Athlon Silver 3050U is the better choice for users whose primary workloads are rendering-based, as evidenced by its consistent ~10.7% lead across all Cinebench tests. Its larger L3 cache, higher boost clock, and more modern 14 nm process with 3,500 million transistors all point to an architecture better suited for sustained multi-threaded creative tasks. The lower 15 W TDP also makes it more suitable for thin-and-light laptops where thermal management is a priority.
The Intel Core i5-4288U is the better choice for general-purpose computing and legacy application performance. Its 33.3% lead in Geekbench multicore and 11.6% lead in single-core indicate that it handles a wider range of everyday tasks with more agility. The higher 2.60 GHz base clock suggests it can maintain performance under sustained loads without relying on boost states. For a user who prioritizes system snappiness in office, web, and photo-editing tasks, the Intel chip’s benchmark profile is superior. The Intel chip’s 28 W TDP is higher, but that may be a trade-off for its superior general performance in the Geekbench suite. Ultimately, the choice hinges on workload: AMD for rendering, Intel for everything else.