AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G vs Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3 Comparison
AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G
Xeon E5-1630 v3
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G vs Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3
The AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G and Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3 are two very different four-core processors that land in nearly the same performance bracket. The data shows a remarkably consistent pattern: the AMD part wins every single benchmark in the head-to-head comparison, but the margins are razor-thin across the board. This is a classic case of two architectures from different eras converging on similar results, with the newer AMD chip holding a slight edge in every test.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The most striking finding is the uniformity of the results. Across six Cinebench tests spanning three versions (R15, R20, and R23), the AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G wins all six. The largest margin comes in Cinebench R15 single-core, where the AMD chip scores 90 against the Xeon's 89, a 1.1% advantage. The smallest gap is in R15 multi-core, where the AMD scores 639 versus 635, just a 0.6% difference.
The multi-core results tell a particularly interesting story. In Cinebench R20 multi-core, the AMD scores 2665 against the Xeon's 2647, a 0.7% lead. In R23 multi-core, the AMD scores 6347 versus 6303, again a 0.7% margin. These are negligible differences in real-world terms, yet they consistently favor the Athlon. That the AMD chip achieves this with 4 threads against the Xeon's 8 threads makes the result more notable — the Athlon is doing more work per thread, or at least matching the Xeon's parallel throughput while using half the thread count.
Single-core results follow the same pattern. The AMD wins R15 single-core by 1.1%, R20 single-core by 0.8% (376 vs 373), and R23 single-core by 0.8% (896 vs 889). These margins are small but consistent, suggesting the AMD's newer Zen+ architecture has a modest per-core advantage over the Haswell-based Xeon, despite the Xeon's higher base clock of 3.70 GHz versus the AMD's 3.50 GHz.
Looking at the broader benchmark context, both processors sit at the 42nd percentile of all CPUs. The AMD's average benchmark score is 1836, while the Xeon's is 1823 — a 0.7% difference in the AMD's favor. The nearest rivals for the AMD include the Intel Core i5-8305G (1831, 0.3% behind) and Intel Core i7-8706G (1842, 0.3% ahead), placing the Athlon in a tight cluster of mid-range performers. The Xeon's rivals include the Intel Core i7-4790S (1827, 0.2% behind) and Intel Xeon D-1537 (1830, 0.4% behind), showing it sits in a similarly crowded performance band.
Architecture Differences
The two chips come from fundamentally different design philosophies and eras. The AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G uses the Zen+ architecture, codenamed Picasso, built on a 12 nm process at GlobalFoundries. It packs 4,940 million transistors onto a 210 mm² die. The Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3 uses the Haswell architecture, codenamed Haswell-EP, on Intel's 22 nm process, with 2,600 million transistors on a much larger 356 mm² die.
Cache configurations differ significantly. The AMD provides 96 KB of L1 cache per core and 512 KB of L2 per core, with a 4 MB shared L3 cache. The Intel offers smaller per-core caches — 64 KB L1 and 256 KB L2 — but compensates with a much larger 10 MB shared L3 cache. This means the Xeon has 2.5 times the L3 cache, which can be important for workloads that repeatedly access a large working set.
Thread counts also diverge. The AMD is a pure 4-core, 4-thread part with no simultaneous multithreading. The Intel is a 4-core, 8-thread processor, doubling the thread count via Hyper-Threading. Despite this, the AMD still edges out the Xeon in multi-core benchmarks, which raises questions about how effectively the Xeon's extra threads are being utilized in these Cinebench workloads.
Memory subsystems differ as well. Both support DDR4, but the AMD runs dual-channel with a memory bandwidth of 46.9 GB/s, while the Intel runs quad-channel with 68.3 GB/s — a 45.6% bandwidth advantage for the Xeon. Both support ECC memory, which is expected given the Xeon's server/workstation positioning and the AMD's PRO branding. The AMD uses PCIe Gen 4, while the Intel uses PCIe Gen 3 with 40 lanes (CPU only).
The integrated graphics situation is a major differentiator. The AMD includes Radeon Vega 3 graphics, while the Intel Xeon has no integrated graphics at all. This means the Athlon can power a display without a discrete GPU, while the Xeon requires a separate graphics card. Power consumption also differs dramatically: the AMD is rated at 65 W TDP, while the Intel is rated at 140 W — more than double.
The Verdict
The benchmark data is unambiguous: the AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G wins every head-to-head comparison, but the margins are so small that they may not matter in practice. A 0.6% to 1.1% difference in Cinebench scores is within run-to-run variance for most workloads. The data suggests these processors are effectively equivalent in raw CPU performance, with the AMD holding a slight but consistent edge.
That said, the data also reveals important context beyond raw scores. The AMD does this with 4 threads against the Xeon's 8, with a smaller L3 cache (4 MB vs 10 MB), and with less than half the TDP (65 W vs 140 W). The AMD also brings integrated graphics, which the Xeon lacks entirely. From a pure capability standpoint, the Athlon offers comparable performance with significantly lower power draw and added features.
However, the Xeon's quad-channel memory support and 40 PCIe Gen 3 lanes give it a platform-level advantage for certain workstation tasks that depend on memory bandwidth or high lane counts. The Xeon's 68.3 GB/s memory bandwidth versus the AMD's 46.9 GB/s is a substantial gap that could matter in memory-bound applications, even if Cinebench doesn't expose it. The Xeon also targets the server/workstation market segment with its 2014 release, while the AMD is a desktop part from 2020.
FAQ
Q: Which processor wins more benchmarks in the head-to-head comparison?
A: The AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G wins all six head-to-head benchmarks, with margins ranging from 0.6% to 1.1% over the Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3.
Q: How does the thread count differ between the two chips?
A: The AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G has 4 cores and 4 threads, while the Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3 has 4 cores and 8 threads due to Hyper-Threading.
Q: Does the Intel Xeon have integrated graphics?
A: No, the Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3 has no integrated graphics. The AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G includes Radeon Vega 3 integrated graphics.
Q: What is the memory bandwidth difference between the two?
A: The AMD supports dual-channel memory with 46.9 GB/s bandwidth, while the Intel supports quad-channel memory with 68.3 GB/s bandwidth.
Q: Which processor has a larger L3 cache?
A: The Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3 has a 10 MB shared L3 cache, while the AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G has a 4 MB shared L3 cache.
Q: What are the TDP ratings for each processor?
A: The AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G has a 65 W TDP, while the Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3 has a 140 W TDP.
Where Each One Wins
The AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G wins on every Cinebench benchmark in the head-to-head comparison. Its advantages include integrated Radeon Vega 3 graphics, a lower 65 W TDP, PCIe Gen 4 support, a smaller die size (210 mm²), and a higher transistor count (4,940 million). It is also an active production part, while the Xeon is end-of-life. For users who need a compact, power-efficient desktop system with graphics capability and no discrete GPU, the AMD is the clear choice based on this data.
The Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3 wins on platform-level specifications rather than benchmark scores. It offers 8 threads versus 4, a 10 MB L3 cache versus 4 MB, quad-channel memory with 68.3 GB/s bandwidth versus dual-channel 46.9 GB/s, and 40 PCIe Gen 3 lanes. Its larger 356 mm² die and 2,600 million transistors reflect an older, more power-hungry design. For server or workstation builds where memory bandwidth, cache capacity, and PCIe lane count are critical — and where a discrete GPU is already required — the Xeon's platform features could provide advantages in workloads not captured by these Cinebench results.
Specification Differences
| Specification | AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G | Intel Xeon E5-1630 v3 |
|---|---|---|
| Threads | 4 | 8 |
| Base Clock | 3.50 GHz | 3.70 GHz |
| Boost Clock | 3.90 GHz | 3.80 GHz |
| TDP | 65 W | 140 W |
| Socket | AMD Socket AM4 | Intel Socket 2011-3 |
| Architecture | Zen+ | Haswell |
| Codename | Picasso | Haswell-EP |
| Process Node | 12 nm | 22 nm |
| Foundry | GlobalFoundries | Intel |
| Transistors | 4,940 million | 2,600 million |
| Die Size | 210 mm² | 356 mm² |
| L1 Cache | 96 KB (per core) | 64 KB (per core) |
| L2 Cache | 512 KB (per core) | 256 KB (per core) |
| L3 Cache | 4 MB (shared) | 10 MB (shared) |
| Memory Bus | Dual-channel | Quad-channel |
| Memory Bandwidth | 46.9 GB/s | 68.3 GB/s |
| PCIe | Gen 4 | Gen 3, 40 Lanes (CPU only) |
| Integrated Graphics | Radeon Vega 3 | None |
| Market Segment | Desktop | Server/Workstation |
| Production Status | Active | End-of-life |
| Release Date | 2020-07-20 | 2014-09-07 |
| Part Number | YD3150C5M4MFH | QFSVSR20L |