AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G vs Intel Core i7-8706G Comparison
AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G
Core i7-8706G
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G vs Intel Core i7-8706G
The Intel Core i7-8706G and AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G sit nearly dead even in aggregate performance, separated by a mere 6 points in average benchmark score (1842 vs 1836). Both land at the 42nd percentile of all CPUs, making them direct mid-pack rivals. The data shows the Intel part wins every single Cinebench test in the head-to-head, but the margins are razor-thin, with the largest gap being just 0.3%. This is a matchup where architectural differences and platform features matter far more than raw compute scores.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The Cinebench results tell a story of near-perfect parity. In Cinebench R15 multicore, the i7-8706G scores 641 against the Athlon's 639, a 0.3% lead for Intel. Single-core R15 is an exact tie at 90 points each, with a deltaPct of 0. Moving to Cinebench R20, Intel again takes multicore by 0.3% (2674 vs 2665) and single-core by the same margin (377 vs 376). The pattern repeats in Cinebench R23: Intel leads multicore 6368 to 6347 and single-core 899 to 896, both at 0.3%.
These deltas are statistically insignificant in practical terms. A 0.3% difference means roughly 20 points in multicore R23, which is within run-to-run variance for most systems. The Intel chip wins all six head-to-head tests, but it is a clean sweep by a hair's breadth rather than a knockout. For context, the i7-8706G's nearest rival, the Intel Core i5-7600, scores 1844 on average — just 0.1% above it. The Athlon's nearest rival, the AMD Ryzen 5 4600U, averages 1832, which is 0.2% below it. Both processors are effectively interchangeable in pure CPU throughput.
The single-core results are particularly telling. A 90-point tie in R15 and a 1-point difference in R20 (377 vs 376) indicate that per-thread performance is nearly identical despite the architectural gap. This is surprising given that the i7-8706G has a 4.10 GHz boost clock versus the Athlon's 3.90 GHz, but the Zen+ architecture in the AMD part compensates with its 3.50 GHz base clock, which is higher than Intel's 3.10 GHz.
FAQ
Q: Which processor has more threads?
A: The Intel Core i7-8706G has 8 threads from its 4 cores, while the AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G has 4 threads from its 4 cores. Hyper-Threading gives Intel a 2x thread advantage, yet the benchmark scores show only a 0.3% difference in multicore tests.
Q: What is the average benchmark score difference between the two?
A: The i7-8706G averages 1842 points, and the Athlon Gold PRO 3150G averages 1836 points. That is a 6-point gap, or roughly 0.3%, putting both at the 42nd percentile of all CPUs.
Q: Does the AMD processor support ECC memory?
A: Yes, the Athlon Gold PRO 3150G supports ECC memory. The Intel Core i7-8706G does not, as its memory support is listed as DDR4 with ECC set to false.
Q: What are the socket requirements for each?
A: The Intel Core i7-8706G uses the Intel BGA 2270 socket, which is a mobile platform. The AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G uses the AMD Socket AM4, a desktop platform. These are not interchangeable.
Q: Which processor has a larger L3 cache?
A: The Intel Core i7-8706G has 8 MB of shared L3 cache, double the Athlon's 4 MB shared L3. Despite this, the Athlon's per-core L2 cache is larger at 512 KB per core versus Intel's 256 KB per core.
Q: What is the process node difference?
A: The Intel part is built on Intel's 14 nm process, while the AMD part uses a 12 nm node from GlobalFoundries. The AMD chip has a smaller transistor footprint per area, though the Intel chip's die details are not provided.
The Verdict
From the data alone, the Intel Core i7-8706G is the winner on paper, claiming all six Cinebench tests. But the margins are so small that no real-world application would consistently favor it over the Athlon. The i7-8706G's 8 threads give it a theoretical advantage in heavily threaded workloads, yet Cinebench R23 multicore shows only a 21-point lead (6368 vs 6347), which is less than 0.4%. The Athlon's higher base clock (3.50 GHz vs 3.10 GHz) partially compensates for its lack of SMT, keeping single-core performance nearly identical.
The choice comes down to platform, not performance. The i7-8706G is a mobile part on BGA 2270, meaning it is soldered to a board and not upgradeable. The Athlon Gold PRO 3150G is a desktop part on AM4, offering a replaceable CPU in a standard socket. For anyone building a new system, the AM4 platform provides far more flexibility, including PCIe Gen 4 support, which the Intel part lacks entirely (no PCIe version is listed). The Athlon also supports ECC memory, a feature absent from the Intel chip.
If you are locked into a laptop or a proprietary all-in-one with BGA 2270, the i7-8706G is the better choice because it wins every benchmark and offers 8 threads. But for a desktop build, the Athlon's socket compatibility, ECC support, and PCIe Gen 4 make it the more practical pick despite losing by 0.3% in every test. Neither chip is a performance leader; both sit at the 42nd percentile, so buyers should prioritize platform features over the negligible score differences.
Specification Differences
The two CPUs differ in nearly every fundamental specification. The Intel Core i7-8706G has 4 cores and 8 threads, while the AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G has 4 cores and 4 threads. Base clocks are 3.10 GHz for Intel and 3.50 GHz for AMD, but boost clocks favor Intel at 4.10 GHz versus 3.90 GHz. Both have a 65 W TDP.
The memory support is DDR4 for both, but the AMD part specifies dual-channel operation with 46.9 GB/s bandwidth, while the Intel part lists no memory bus or bandwidth details. ECC memory is supported on the AMD chip and not on the Intel chip. PCIe support is Gen 4 for AMD, with no PCIe data listed for Intel.
Integrated graphics differ: Intel uses Radeon RX Vega M GL, while AMD uses Radeon Vega 3. The market segments are Mobile for Intel and Desktop for AMD. Release dates are January 2018 for Intel and July 2020 for AMD. The AMD part has a part number (YD3150C5M4MFH), while the Intel part has none listed. Neither has an unlocked multiplier.
Architecture Differences
The architectural split is significant. Intel's i7-8706G is built on Kaby Lake, specifically Kaby Lake G, using a 14 nm process from Intel's own foundry. It has a per-core L1 cache of 64 KB and per-core L2 of 256 KB, with 8 MB shared L3. AMD's Athlon Gold PRO 3150G uses Zen+ architecture (codenamed Picasso) on a 12 nm process from GlobalFoundries, with 4,940 million transistors and a 210 mm² die size. Its per-core L1 is 96 KB, per-core L2 is 512 KB, and shared L3 is 4 MB.
The core designs differ fundamentally: Zen+ uses a different instruction scheduling and cache hierarchy than Kaby Lake, with larger per-core caches but half the L3 total. The 12 nm node gives AMD a process advantage in density, though the Intel part's smaller L1 and L2 are offset by its larger shared L3. The i7-8706G supports SMT (simultaneous multithreading) to reach 8 threads, while the Athlon does not. The integrated GPU also differs: Intel pairs with a Radeon RX Vega M GL, a high-end mobile GPU, while AMD uses its own Radeon Vega 3, a basic integrated solution.
Where Each One Wins
The Intel Core i7-8706G wins in every benchmark test, so it is objectively faster in Cinebench workloads. The multicore advantage comes from its 8 threads; in R23, it scores 6368 vs 6347. Single-core wins are marginal, with a 3-point lead in R23 (899 vs 896). The Intel part also wins on L3 cache capacity, having 8 MB versus 4 MB, which can help in cache-sensitive applications. Its integrated Radeon RX Vega M GL is a stronger GPU than the Radeon Vega 3, making it better for light gaming or GPU-accelerated tasks without a discrete card.
The AMD Athlon Gold PRO 3150G wins on platform features. It offers ECC memory support, which is critical for error-sensitive workstation tasks. Its PCIe Gen 4 support provides double the bandwidth of older standards, benefiting NVMe storage and future GPUs. The AM4 socket is a mainstream desktop standard with broad motherboard availability and upgrade paths, unlike Intel's BGA 2270, which is soldered. The Athlon's higher base clock (3.50 GHz) gives it better sustained performance in single-threaded, non-boost scenarios. Its 12 nm process and 210 mm² die size with 4,940 million transistors indicate a more modern manufacturing approach, and the dual-channel memory bandwidth of 46.9 GB/s is explicitly documented. For a builder prioritizing longevity, ECC support, or PCIe Gen 4, the Athlon is the strategic choice despite losing all six benchmark matchups.