AMD Athlon Gold 3150G vs Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3 Comparison
AMD Athlon Gold 3150G
Xeon E5-1620 v3
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD Athlon Gold 3150G vs Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3
The Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3 and AMD Athlon Gold 3150G are two four-core processors from different eras and market segments, yet benchmark results place them nearly dead even. The Xeon, a 2014 server/workstation part, and the Athlon, a 2020 desktop chip, both land at the 40th percentile among all CPUs. Their average benchmark scores differ by only 8 points (1709 vs 1701). The data shows the Xeon wins all six head-to-head Cinebench tests, but every victory is narrow, ranging from 0.5% to 1.2%. For a builder, this pairing is a study in contrasts: one offers server-grade memory bandwidth and ECC support, the other brings a modern socket, an unlocked multiplier, and integrated graphics. The practical verdict hinges on what you value beyond raw compute, as raw compute is essentially a tie.
The Verdict
Pick the Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3 if your workload demands maximum memory throughput or error-correcting memory. Its quad-channel DDR4 bus delivers 68.3 GB/s of bandwidth, a 45.6% advantage over the Athlon's dual-channel 46.9 GB/s. The Xeon also supports ECC memory, a critical feature for long-running compute tasks where data corruption is unacceptable. Its 40 PCIe Gen 3 lanes (CPU only) dwarf the Athlon's Gen 4 support, though the Athlon's newer standard offers higher per-lane bandwidth. The Xeon is end-of-life, so it is a scavenger's pick for a workstation build on Intel Socket 2011-3.
Pick the AMD Athlon Gold 3150G if you want a current, active platform with flexibility. It is an unlocked multiplier CPU (the Xeon is locked), making it the choice for tuning. It includes Radeon Vega 3 integrated graphics, so no discrete GPU is required for a basic system. Its 65W TDP is less than half the Xeon's 140W, making cooling and power delivery simpler. The Athlon's Socket AM4 is a mainstream desktop platform with active production status, while the Xeon's platform is dead. For a new build, the Athlon is the more sensible foundation, despite its slight benchmark deficits.
Where Each One Wins
The benchmark data shows the Xeon winning every single Cinebench test, but the margins are trivial. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Xeon scores 595 against 592 (0.5% delta). In R20 multi-core, it is 2482 vs 2470 (0.5%). The single-core results are similarly close: R15 shows 84 vs 83 (1.2%), R20 shows 350 vs 348 (0.6%), and R23 shows 834 vs 830 (0.5%). The biggest relative win for the Xeon is in Cinebench R15 single-core at 1.2%, which is still within run-to-run variance for most systems.
The Athlon's wins are not in compute but in platform attributes. It has a higher boost clock (3.90 GHz vs 3.60 GHz), which may help in short, lightly threaded bursts, though the benchmark scores do not reflect an advantage. It is built on a smaller 12 nm process (vs 22 nm), making it more power-efficient per core. The integrated Radeon Vega 3 GPU is a decisive win for any system that needs display output without an add-in card. The Athlon's unlocked multiplier adds tuning headroom the Xeon lacks.
Architecture Differences
The Xeon E5-1620 v3 is based on Haswell-EP, a 22 nm Intel design with 2,600 million transistors on a 356 mm² die. It has 4 cores and 8 threads, with 64 KB L1 and 256 KB L2 per core, plus a shared 10 MB L3 cache. Its memory controller is quad-channel DDR4, and it uses the Intel Socket 2011-3 platform. This is a server/workstation part with a 140W TDP, designed for sustained load and high I/O capacity.
The Athlon Gold 3150G is a Zen+ "Picasso" chip, manufactured by GlobalFoundries on a 12 nm process. It packs 4,940 million transistors into a 210 mm² die. It has 4 cores and 4 threads (no SMT), with 96 KB L1 and 512 KB L2 per core, and a 4 MB shared L3 cache. It uses dual-channel DDR4 on AMD Socket AM4. The integrated Radeon Vega 3 GPU is present, and the chip is unlocked. Its 65W TDP targets mainstream desktop efficiency. The Athlon supports PCIe Gen 4, while the Xeon is limited to Gen 3.
FAQ
Q: Which CPU has more threads?
A: The Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3 has 8 threads (4 cores with Hyper-Threading), while the AMD Athlon Gold 3150G has 4 threads (4 cores without SMT).
Q: Does the AMD Athlon Gold 3150G have integrated graphics?
A: Yes, it includes Radeon Vega 3 integrated graphics. The Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3 has no integrated graphics.
Q: Which CPU supports ECC memory?
A: The Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3 supports ECC memory. The AMD Athlon Gold 3150G does not.
Q: Is one CPU significantly faster in multi-core benchmarks?
A: No. The Xeon leads in all Cinebench multi-core tests, but by only 0.5% in R15, R20, and R23. The scores are effectively identical for practical purposes.
Q: Which CPU is more power-efficient?
A: The AMD Athlon Gold 3150G has a 65W TDP, compared to the Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3's 140W TDP. The Athlon also uses a smaller 12 nm process node.
Q: Can I overclock either of these CPUs?
A: The AMD Athlon Gold 3150G has an unlocked multiplier, allowing overclocking. The Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3 is multiplier-locked.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The head-to-head data is remarkably consistent: the Xeon wins all six tests, but never by more than 1.2%. In Cinebench R15 multi-core, the Xeon scores 595 against 592, a 0.5% delta. Single-core R15 shows the Xeon at 84 vs 83, a 1.2% delta — the largest margin in the entire comparison. Moving to Cinebench R20, multi-core is 2482 vs 2470 (0.5%), and single-core is 350 vs 348 (0.6%). In the most recent Cinebench R23, multi-core is 5910 vs 5883 (0.5%), and single-core is 834 vs 830 (0.5%). These deltas are so small that they fall within normal thermal and boost variance. The Xeon's consistent, if marginal, lead suggests its 8 threads provide a slight edge in multi-threaded rendering, while its higher base clock matches the Athlon's lower boost in single-threaded tasks.
The biggest win for the Xeon is single-core R15 at 1.2%, but even that is not enough to declare a meaningful performance king. The Athlon's higher boost clock (3.90 GHz vs 3.60 GHz) does not translate into a single-core win in any test. The fact that the Athlon loses despite a 0.30 GHz boost advantage points to Intel's Haswell IPC being comparable to AMD's Zen+ at these low core counts. For practical purposes, these two CPUs are performance twins in Cinebench workloads.
Specification Differences
| Specification | Intel Xeon E5-1620 v3 | AMD Athlon Gold 3150G |
|---|---|---|
| Cores | 4 | 4 |
| Threads | 8 | 4 |
| Base Clock | 3.50 GHz | 3.50 GHz |
| Boost Clock | 3.60 GHz | 3.90 GHz |
| TDP | 140W | 65W |
| Socket | Intel Socket 2011-3 | AMD Socket AM4 |
| Architecture | Haswell | Zen+ |
| Process Node | 22 nm | 12 nm |
| Transistors | 2,600 million | 4,940 million |
| Die Size | 356 mm² | 210 mm² |
| L1 Cache | 64 KB (per core) | 96 KB (per core) |
| L2 Cache | 256 KB (per core) | 512 KB (per core) |
| L3 Cache | 10 MB (shared) | 4 MB (shared) |
| Memory Bus | Quad-channel | Dual-channel |
| Memory Bandwidth | 68.3 GB/s | 46.9 GB/s |
| ECC Memory | Yes | No |
| PCIe | Gen 3, 40 Lanes (CPU only) | Gen 4 |
| Integrated Graphics | None | Radeon Vega 3 |
| Market Segment | Server/Workstation | Desktop |
| Production Status | End-of-life | Active |
| Release Date | 2014-09-07 | 2020-07-20 |
| Multiplier Unlocked | No | Yes |
The differences tell a clear platform story. The Xeon is a server-grade part with quad-channel memory, ECC support, and a massive 40 PCIe Gen 3 lanes, all wrapped in a 140W package. The Athlon is a modern desktop chip with a smaller process node, half the TDP, an unlocked multiplier, integrated graphics, and PCIe Gen 4 support. The Xeon has more L3 cache (10 MB vs 4 MB) and more threads, while the Athlon has larger L1 and L2 caches per core. The Xeon's 2,600 million transistors on 356 mm² contrast with the Athlon's 4,940 million on 210 mm², reflecting the density advantage of 12 nm over 22 nm.