AMD A10-5800B vs Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 Comparison
AMD A10-5800B
Core 2 Extreme QX9650
PERFORMANCE BENCHMARKS
Analysis: AMD A10-5800B vs Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650
The AMD A10-5800B and Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 are two very different quad-core desktop processors from different eras, yet they land in the same performance tier according to aggregate data. The A10-5800B is a 2012 Piledriver-based APU with integrated graphics, while the QX9650 is a 2007 Yorkfield-based CPU from Intel’s enthusiast Core 2 Extreme line. Benchmark results show a clear split: the Intel chip wins both shared tests, but the AMD part counters with a more modern feature set and far lower power draw.
Head-to-Head Benchmarks
The only two benchmarks shared between these processors are Geekbench multicore and singlecore tests. In the Geekbench multicore test, the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 scores 1443 against the AMD A10-5800B’s 1128. That is a 21.8% deficit for the AMD part, a substantial margin that indicates the older Intel chip handles multi-threaded workloads more efficiently despite its lower clock speed. The QX9650’s advantage stems from its architecture and cache design, not raw frequency, since it runs at a 3.00 GHz base clock with no boost, while the A10-5800B runs at 3.80 GHz base and boosts to 4.20 GHz.
The single-core picture is closer but still favors Intel. The QX9650 scores 509 in Geekbench singlecore, while the A10-5800B manages 459. That is a 9.8% difference, roughly half the gap seen in the multicore test. This suggests the Intel core design is more efficient per clock, allowing it to overcome a 0.80 GHz frequency disadvantage. For everyday tasks that rely on one or two threads, the QX9650 holds a measurable but not overwhelming edge.
Looking at the broader benchmark landscape, the QX9650 also has additional Cinebench scores that the A10-5800B lacks entirely. In Cinebench R15 multicore, it scores 209; in R20 multicore, 872; in R20 singlecore, 123; in R23 multicore, 2077; and in R23 singlecore, 293. These results reinforce the Geekbench findings, showing a CPU that is consistently competitive in both single- and multi-threaded tests. The A10-5800B has no corresponding Cinebench data, so direct comparison is impossible there, but the pattern from Geekbench suggests the Intel part would likely lead in those tests as well.
Architecture Differences
The two CPUs are built on fundamentally different designs. The AMD A10-5800B uses the Piledriver architecture on the Trinity codename, fabricated on a 32 nm process at GlobalFoundries. It packs 1,303 million transistors onto a 246 mm² die. The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 uses the Core 2 architecture under the Yorkfield codename, built on a 45 nm process at Intel, with 820 million transistors spread across two dies measuring 107 mm² each. The AMD part is the more recent design, released in October 2012, while the Intel chip dates from November 2007.
Cache configurations diverge sharply. The A10-5800B has 192 KB of L1 cache and 4 MB of shared L2 cache, with no L3 cache at all. The QX9650 has 64 KB of L1 cache per core, totaling 256 KB across four cores, and a much larger 12 MB of shared L2 cache. That 12 MB L2 is a critical advantage for the Intel chip, as it reduces memory latency and improves hit rates on larger working sets. The AMD part’s smaller cache is partially offset by its higher clock speeds, but the benchmark data shows the Intel cache architecture wins out.
Memory support also differs meaningfully. The A10-5800B supports DDR3 memory on a dual-channel bus with a peak bandwidth of 29.9 GB/s. The QX9650 supports DDR1, DDR2, and DDR3 memory, also dual-channel, though its maximum bandwidth is not listed in the data. Both processors use PCIe Gen 2, and neither supports ECC memory. The AMD part includes integrated Radeon HD 7660D graphics, while the Intel chip relies on chipset features for display output on certain motherboards, which is not true integrated graphics.
Other differences include socket type: the A10-5800B uses AMD Socket FM2, while the QX9650 uses Intel Socket 775. The AMD chip’s multiplier is locked, whereas the Intel chip’s multiplier is unlocked, which historically allowed for easier overclocking. Power consumption is also notably different, with the A10-5800B rated at 100W TDP and the QX9650 at 130W TDP.
Where Each One Wins
The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 wins outright in every shared benchmark, taking both Geekbench multicore and singlecore tests. Its 21.8% multicore lead and 9.8% singlecore lead make it the stronger pure CPU for compute tasks. The additional Cinebench scores, while not directly comparable to the AMD part, show a chip that maintains respectable performance across rendering workloads, with a multicore score of 2077 in Cinebench R23 and a singlecore score of 293. For users running CPU-bound applications like video encoding, 3D rendering, or scientific simulations, the QX9650 is the clear choice based on available data.
The AMD A10-5800B wins in areas not captured by raw CPU benchmarks. It has integrated Radeon HD 7660D graphics, meaning a system built around it does not require a separate graphics card for basic display output. The QX9650 has no integrated graphics and depends on motherboard chipset features, which may or may not provide display capability depending on the board. The AMD part also draws 30W less power (100W vs 130W TDP), which can translate to lower cooling requirements and a more efficient system overall. Its newer 32 nm process and higher clock speeds (3.80 GHz base, 4.20 GHz boost) make it more responsive in lightly threaded tasks, even though the benchmark data shows the Intel chip still edges it out in single-core performance.
For memory bandwidth, the A10-5800B’s 29.9 GB/s is listed explicitly, while the QX9650’s bandwidth is not provided, so a direct comparison is not possible. However, the AMD part’s support for DDR3 only versus the Intel part’s support for DDR1, DDR2, and DDR3 gives the AMD chip a more modern memory path, albeit with no L3 cache to buffer latency.
The Verdict
The data points to a straightforward conclusion: the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 is the faster CPU in raw processing terms. It wins both Geekbench tests by double-digit percentages in multicore and nearly 10% in singlecore, and it holds its own in modern Cinebench workloads. Its 12 MB L2 cache is a decisive advantage that compensates for its lower clock speed. Anyone building a system for CPU-intensive work where the chip is the bottleneck should choose the QX9650, provided they can accommodate its 130W TDP and lack of integrated graphics.
The AMD A10-5800B is the better pick for a different kind of build. If the goal is a simple desktop or media PC without a discrete graphics card, the integrated Radeon HD 7660D makes it a more complete package. Its lower 100W TDP and newer 32 nm process make it easier to cool and more energy-efficient. The locked multiplier is a downside for overclockers, but for standard use, the higher base and boost clocks keep it responsive. For users who value an all-in-one solution over peak CPU throughput, the A10-5800B is the practical choice, even though it trails in every shared benchmark.
There is no scenario in the data where the AMD part wins on performance. The Intel chip leads by 21.8% in multicore and 9.8% in singlecore, and it has no glaring weaknesses in the provided benchmark set. The only reasons to choose the AMD part are its integrated graphics, lower power draw, and more modern platform features. Both CPUs sit at the 21st percentile of all CPUs, indicating they are comparable in the broader market, but within this head-to-head, Intel takes the performance crown.
FAQ
Q: Which CPU has a higher average benchmark score?
A: The AMD A10-5800B has an average benchmark score of 794, while the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 has an average score of 789. The difference is less than 1%, making them statistically equivalent.
Q: How much faster is the Intel chip in Geekbench multicore?
A: The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 scores 1443 versus the AMD A10-5800B’s 1128, a 21.8% advantage for Intel.
Q: Does the AMD A10-5800B have integrated graphics?
A: Yes, it includes Radeon HD 7660D graphics. The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 does not have integrated graphics and relies on chipset features on certain motherboards.
Q: What is the TDP difference between these two processors?
A: The AMD A10-5800B is rated at 100W TDP, while the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 is rated at 130W TDP, making the AMD part 30W lower.
Q: Which CPU supports more memory types?
A: The Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 supports DDR1, DDR2, and DDR3 memory. The AMD A10-5800B supports only DDR3.
Q: Is the Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 overclockable?
A: Yes, its multiplier is unlocked. The AMD A10-5800B has a locked multiplier, so it is not intended for multiplier-based overclocking.
Specification Differences
| Specification | AMD A10-5800B | Intel Core 2 Extreme QX9650 |
|----------------|----------------|-----------------------------|
| Base Clock | 3.80 GHz | 3.00 GHz |
| Boost Clock | 4.20 GHz | None |
| TDP | 100 W | 130 W |
| Socket | AMD Socket FM2 | Intel Socket 775 |
| Architecture | Piledriver | Core 2 |
| Codename | Trinity | Yorkfield |
| Process Node | 32 nm | 45 nm |
| Foundry | GlobalFoundries | Intel |
| Transistors | 1,303 million | 820 million |
| Die Size | 246 mm² | 2x 107 mm² |
| L1 Cache | 192 KB | 64 KB (per core) |
| L2 Cache | 4 MB (shared) | 12 MB (shared) |
| Memory Support | DDR3 | DDR1, DDR2, DDR3 |
| Memory Bandwidth | 29.9 GB/s | Not listed |
| Integrated Graphics | Radeon HD 7660D | On certain motherboards (chipset feature) |
| Multiplier Unlocked | No | Yes |
| Part Number | AD580BWOA44HJ | SLAN3 |
| Release Date | 2012-10-01 | 2007-11-29 (UTC) |