Red Dead Redemption 2
This combination may struggle with this title, averaging 26 FPS. Consider upgrading hardware or significantly lowering settings.
Average FPS: resolution vs quality settings
| Ultra | High | Medium | Low | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4K Ultra HD | 11 | 15 | 18 | 24 |
| 1440p QHD | 17 | 23 | 28 | 37 |
| 1080p Full HD | 22 | 31 | 37 | 50 |
Cell color: green is 120+ FPS, teal is 60+, amber is 30+, red is below 30.
Red Dead Redemption 2 with Intel Core i5-12400 + AMD Radeon RX 580, In-Depth Analysis
The Intel Core i5-12400 paired with the AMD Radeon RX 580 produces a very specific performance envelope in Red Dead Redemption 2, one that is heavily constrained by the graphics card at nearly every setting. The measured data shows a clear and consistent pattern: as resolution increases, the frame rate collapses, indicating that the Polaris GPU is the primary bottleneck across the board. At 1080p with Low settings, the combo achieves an average of 50 FPS, which is the only configuration in the entire measured set that approaches a smooth experience. Moving to 1440p Low drops the average to 37 FPS, a 26% reduction, while 4K Low falls to 24 FPS, a further 35% drop from the 1440p figure. This scaling behavior is typical of a GPU that is running out of pixel throughput and memory bandwidth, not a CPU that is struggling to feed frames.
The data reveals that the gap between settings presets widens dramatically at higher resolutions, which further confirms the GPU-bound nature of this pairing. At 1080p, the difference between Low and High is 19 FPS (50 vs 31), while at 4K, the same settings gap shrinks to 9 FPS (24 vs 15). The frame rate at 4K Ultra is a mere 11 FPS average, which is essentially unplayable, and even the minimum FPS at 1080p Medium is 32, showing that the system cannot hold a stable 30 FPS at that preset. The combination of a 6-core CPU with a 12-thread count and a 2017-era GPU creates a situation where the graphics card is saturated long before the processor can demonstrate any meaningful advantage.
Resolution Scaling
The resolution scaling analysis shows a steep and predictable decline in performance as pixel count increases, with the GPU being the limiting component in every scenario. From 1080p Low to 1440p Low, the average frame rate drops from 50 to 37 FPS, a 13 FPS loss that corresponds to a 26% reduction. The jump from 1440p Low to 4K Low is even more punishing, with the average falling from 37 to 24 FPS, a 35% decrease. This pattern indicates that the RX 580's 256-bit memory bus and 8 GB of GDDR5 are being overwhelmed by the fill rate demands of higher resolutions, particularly in a game as visually dense as Red Dead Redemption 2.
At the High preset, the scaling is similar but starts from a lower baseline. The transition from 1080p High (31 FPS) to 1440p High (23 FPS) represents a 26% drop, and then to 4K High (15 FPS) another 35% drop. The uniformity of these percentage losses across different settings presets is a strong indicator that the bottleneck is purely on the GPU's pixel processing and memory subsystem, not on any CPU-side geometry or draw call processing. The i5-12400, with its boost clock of 4.40 GHz and 18 MB of shared L3 cache, is never the constraining factor here; the data suggests that even a significantly weaker CPU would produce nearly identical frame rates at these settings.
The most telling data point comes from the Ultra preset, where the average frame rate at 4K is 11 FPS. This is a 78% reduction from the 1080p Ultra figure of 22 FPS. The fact that the Ultra preset at 1080p cannot break 30 FPS average indicates that the GPU is already saturated even at the lowest resolution tested with the highest settings. The measured minimum FPS values, available only for the Medium preset, show that at 1080p Medium the system drops to 32 FPS, while at 1440p Medium it falls to 24 FPS, and at 4K Medium to 16 FPS. These minimums are consistently 15-20% below the averages, suggesting occasional stutters even in the playable range.
GPU Role
The AMD Radeon RX 580 is the definitive performance ceiling for this combo in Red Dead Redemption 2, and its specifications explain why the frame rates are so low. The GPU operates with a base clock of 1257 MHz and a boost clock of 1340 MHz, which are modest figures by modern standards, but the real limitation is its 256 GB/s of memory bandwidth and 8 GB of GDDR5 VRAM. The card features 2304 shading units and 32 ROPs, which gives it a pixel rate of 42.88 GPixel/s and a texture rate of 193.0 GTexel/s. These raw throughput numbers, combined with a 6.175 TFLOPS FP32 compute rating, place the card in the 53rd percentile of all GPUs, according to the benchmark database.
The VRAM capacity of 8 GB is sufficient for 1080p and 1440p in this game, but the bandwidth becomes a critical constraint at 4K. The measured data shows that at 4K Medium, the average FPS is 18, with a minimum of 16 and a maximum of 21, which indicates that the card is consistently hitting a memory bandwidth wall. The GPU's nearest rival in the database is the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3050 Ti Mobile, which has an average score of 12940 versus the RX 580's 12928, a delta of -0.1%. This puts the two cards essentially on par in synthetic benchmarks, yet the RX 580's older GCN 4.0 architecture may handle this particular title differently.
The GPU's DirectX 12 support (12_0) and Vulkan 1.3 capability are relevant, as Red Dead Redemption 2 can utilize these APIs, but the card's PassMark DirectX 12 score of 43 is notably lower than its DirectX 11 score of 60. This suggests that the card may perform relatively better under older API paths, though the measured FPS data does not distinguish between API versions. The 185 W TDP and dual-slot design indicate this is a power-hungry card for its performance class, but the power draw is not the limiting factor here—the compute and memory throughput are.
CPU Role
The Intel Core i5-12400 plays a supporting role in this pairing, and the data indicates that it is rarely the bottleneck in Red Dead Redemption 2. The processor features 6 cores and 12 threads, with a base clock of 2.50 GHz and a boost clock of 4.40 GHz, along with 18 MB of shared L3 cache. In synthetic benchmarks, the CPU achieves a Cinebench R23 multicore score of 15989 and a single-core score of 2257, placing it in the 72nd percentile of all CPUs. These figures show that the processor has ample headroom for gaming workloads, which typically rely on strong single-thread performance.
The CPU's nearest rival in the database is the AMD EPYC 7643, which has an average score of 18697 versus the i5-12400's 18683, a delta of -0.1%. This comparison is somewhat misleading, as the EPYC is a server-class chip, but it does illustrate that the i5-12400's multithreaded performance is competitive with much larger processors. The 3DMark single-thread score of 910 and the PassMark single-thread score of 3456 both confirm that the CPU can deliver frames quickly, but in this game, the RX 580 cannot keep up with the CPU's output.
At 1080p Low, the combo achieves 50 FPS average, which is the highest measured result in the entire dataset. If the CPU were the limiting factor, we would expect to see similar frame rates across different resolutions at the same settings, since the CPU's workload is largely resolution-independent. Instead, the data shows a 50% reduction in FPS from 1080p Low to 4K Low (50 to 24), which proves that the GPU is the constraining component. The CPU's 6 cores and 12 threads are more than sufficient for the game's threading model, and the 4.40 GHz boost clock ensures that even single-threaded draw call processing is not a concern.
How This Combo Ranks
Within the benchmark database, this specific combination of the Intel Core i5-12400 and AMD Radeon RX 580 ranks 3389 out of 3714 tested combos in Red Dead Redemption 2. This places the pairing in the bottom 9% of all tested configurations, which is a sobering statistic that reflects the GPU's age and performance class. The combo rank of 3389 out of 3714 means that only 325 other combinations perform worse than this setup, while the vast majority of systems deliver better frame rates in this demanding title.
The low ranking is almost entirely attributable to the RX 580's position in the GPU hierarchy, as the card sits at the 53rd percentile of all GPUs. The CPU, by contrast, is at the 72nd percentile, which suggests that many of the combos ranked above this one feature the same or similar CPUs paired with much faster graphics cards. The data shows that the i5-12400 is capable of driving much higher frame rates, but it is hamstrung by the GPU's 256 GB/s bandwidth and 6.175 TFLOPS compute limit.
It is important to note that the combo rank does not differentiate between resolutions or settings; it is an aggregate measure across all tested conditions. Given that the best case scenario for this combo is 50 FPS at 1080p Low, it is clear that the system is only suitable for low-to-medium settings at 1080p, and even then, it will struggle to maintain smooth gameplay in demanding scenes. The rank of 3389 out of 3714 is a clear warning that this is not a high-performance gaming configuration, but rather a legacy setup that can handle older or less demanding titles with reasonable settings.
FAQ
Q: What is the best average frame rate this combo can achieve in Red Dead Redemption 2?
A: The highest measured average frame rate is 50 FPS, which occurs at 1920x1080 resolution with Low settings.
Q: Can this system run the game at 4K resolution?
A: The data shows that 4K is not viable, with average frame rates of 15 FPS at High, 18 FPS at Medium, and 24 FPS at Low settings.
Q: How does the RX 580 compare to its nearest rival in the database?
A: The RX 580 has an average benchmark score of 12928, which is 0.1% lower than the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3050 Ti Mobile's score of 12940.
Q: Is the CPU or GPU the limiting factor in this game?
A: The GPU is the limiting factor, as evidenced by the 50% frame rate drop from 1080p Low (50 FPS) to 4K Low (24 FPS), which would not occur if the CPU were the bottleneck.
Q: What is the minimum frame rate recorded for this combo?
A: The lowest minimum frame rate recorded is 16 FPS, which occurs at 3840x2160 resolution with Medium settings.
Q: How does the i5-12400's single-thread performance compare to its multicore performance?
A: The CPU achieves a Cinebench R23 single-core score of 2257 and a multicore score of 15989, showing strong single-thread capability that is not fully utilized in this GPU-bound scenario.
Measured FPS Breakdown
The complete measured FPS data for this combo in Red Dead Redemption 2 is as follows. At 1920x1080, the Low preset yields an average of 50 FPS, which is the only result that approaches playable smoothness. The Medium preset at the same resolution produces 37 FPS average, with a minimum of 32 and a maximum of 43 FPS. High settings at 1080p drop the average to 31 FPS, while Ultra settings fall further to 22 FPS. These results show a clear linear progression: each step up in settings costs roughly 8-9 FPS at 1080p.
Moving to 2560x1440, the Low preset delivers 37 FPS average, which is identical to the 1080p Medium figure, highlighting how resolution and settings trade off against each other. The Medium preset at 1440p achieves 28 FPS average, with a minimum of 24 and a maximum of 32 FPS. High settings at 1440p produce 23 FPS, and Ultra settings drop to 17 FPS. The pattern at 1440p shows that even Low settings cannot maintain a solid 40 FPS, and any preset above Low will result in sub-30 FPS gameplay.
At 3840x2160, the results are uniformly poor. The Low preset yields 24 FPS average, which is technically the highest 4K result, but still below playable thresholds. Medium settings at 4K produce 18 FPS average, with a minimum of 16 and a maximum of 21 FPS. High settings drop to 15 FPS, and Ultra settings bottom out at 11 FPS. The 4K data shows that the GPU is completely overwhelmed, with even the lowest settings failing to reach 25 FPS. The minimum FPS values recorded only for the Medium preset across all resolutions show a consistent pattern of 15-20% drops below the average, indicating that frame pacing is not the issue—raw throughput is.
Settings Recommendations
Based on the measured data, the only configuration that provides a consistently playable experience is 1920x1080 with Low settings, which delivers a 50 FPS average. This is the single result that approaches the 60 FPS target, and even it will likely dip in demanding scenes, though the data does not provide a minimum FPS for this preset. For players who prioritize smoothness over visual fidelity, this is the recommended setup, as it is the only one that offers a comfortable margin above the 30 FPS playability threshold.
The 1080p Medium preset, with its 37 FPS average and 32 FPS minimum, is a compromise option for those who want slightly better visuals without falling below 30 FPS. The minimum of 32 FPS indicates that the system can hold above the playable threshold in most situations, but the margin is thin. The 1440p Low preset also achieves 37 FPS average, but without a recorded minimum, it is riskier to recommend, as the 1080p Medium's minimum of 32 FPS provides more confidence in sustained performance.
All High and Ultra presets, as well as all 4K resolutions, should be avoided based on the data. The 1080p High preset's 31 FPS average is borderline, but the lack of a minimum FPS measurement means it could dip below 30 FPS regularly. The 1440p Medium preset's 28 FPS average and 24 FPS minimum confirms that sub-30 FPS gameplay is a real possibility. For the best experience per the measured rows, the clear choice is 1080p Low, with 1080p Medium as a secondary option if visual quality is prioritized over a larger frame rate cushion.
Hardware Specifications
Intel Core i5-12400
AMD Radeon RX 580
FPS Benchmarks by Resolution & Settings
Performance data for Intel Core i5-12400 + AMD Radeon RX 580 in Red Dead Redemption 2
| Resolution | Settings | Avg FPS |
|---|---|---|
| 3840x2160 | Low | 24.0 |
| 3840x2160 | Medium | 18.0 |
| 3840x2160 | High | 15.0 |
| 3840x2160 | Ultra | 11.0 |
| 2560x1440 | Low | 37.0 |
| 2560x1440 | Medium | 28.0 |
| 2560x1440 | High | 23.0 |
| 2560x1440 | Ultra | 17.0 |
| 1920x1080 | Low | 50.0 |
| 1920x1080 | Medium | 37.0 |
| 1920x1080 | High | 31.0 |
| 1920x1080 | Ultra | 22.0 |
Red Dead Redemption 2 with ii5-12400 + Other GPUs
See how Red Dead Redemption 2 performs with the same CPU but different graphics cards.
Red Dead Redemption 2 with RX 580 + Other CPUs
See how Red Dead Redemption 2 performs with the same GPU but different processors.
Other Games with ii5-12400 + RX 580
Explore FPS benchmarks for other games using this same hardware combination.