Hard West
This combination provides smooth gameplay with an average of 61 FPS, suitable for most gaming scenarios.
Average FPS: resolution vs quality settings
| Ultra | High | Medium | Low | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4K Ultra HD | 19 | 28 | 35 | 46 |
| 1440p QHD | 37 | 48 | 68 | 81 |
| 1080p Full HD | 63 | 81 | 103 | 127 |
Cell color: green is 120+ FPS, teal is 60+, amber is 30+, red is below 30.
Hard West with Intel Core i5-9400 + NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1070, In-Depth Analysis
The Intel Core i5-9400 and NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1070 combination delivers its best experience at 1080p with Medium settings, where the 103.2 FPS average represents a 63% improvement over Ultra settings at the same resolution. This pairing is clearly CPU-limited at lower resolutions and GPU-limited at 4K, with the data showing a predictable scaling pattern that favors high refresh rate gaming over 4K fidelity.
Settings Recommendations
For 1080p displays, Medium settings provide the optimal balance, delivering 103.2 FPS average compared to 127.1 FPS on Low and 81.1 FPS on High. The jump from Low to Medium costs 23.9 FPS but yields substantial visual improvements, while the step from Medium to High costs another 22.1 FPS for diminishing returns. Ultra settings at 63.2 FPS remain playable but sacrifice 40 FPS compared to Medium, making it a poor trade-off for a turn-based tactics title where smooth camera panning benefits from higher frame rates.
At 1440p, Medium settings again emerge as the sweet spot with 67.7 FPS average, comfortably above the 60 FPS threshold. High settings at 48.3 FPS remain acceptable for this genre, but the 19.4 FPS drop from Medium makes High less attractive. Ultra at 37.2 FPS drops below ideal smoothness, while Low at 80.5 FPS feels unnecessarily degraded for the visual fidelity lost.
At 4K, no setting achieves a playable 60 FPS average. Medium delivers 35 FPS, High drops to 28 FPS, and Ultra falls to 18.5 FPS. Low settings at 45.7 FPS are the only 4K option approaching playability, but the visual compromise undermines the purpose of 4K resolution. For this combo, 4K should be avoided entirely; 1440p Medium or 1080p Medium/High provide the best experiences.
FAQ
Q: What is the best overall settings preset for this hardware combination?
A: Medium settings at 1080p deliver 103.2 FPS average, representing the best balance of visual quality and performance. This is 40 FPS faster than Ultra and 22.1 FPS faster than High at the same resolution.
Q: Can this combo handle 4K gaming?
A: No. The highest average FPS at 3840x2160 is 45.7 FPS on Low settings, with Medium at 35 FPS, High at 28 FPS, and Ultra at 18.5 FPS. None of these reach the 60 FPS threshold for smooth gameplay.
Q: How does the GTX 1070 compare to its nearest rivals in synthetic benchmarks?
A: The GTX 1070 scores 13498 in Passmark G3D, putting it 0.7% ahead of the Quadro K4200 (12241) and 1.4% behind the GTX 1650 SUPER (12504). Its average benchmark score of 12331 places it in the 51st percentile of all GPUs.
Q: What is the CPU's performance profile relative to similar processors?
A: The i5-9400 has an average benchmark score of 2305, placing it in the 50th percentile. It is 0.2% ahead of the Core i3-10305 (2300) and 0.4% ahead of the Xeon E-2134 (2295), while sitting 0.6% behind the Core i7-8809G (2319).
Q: Does the game scale better with CPU or GPU upgrades?
A: The scaling pattern indicates that at 1080p, the i5-9400's six cores are the limiting factor, as frame rates drop 23.9% from Low to High settings. At 4K, the GTX 1070's 8 GB of VRAM and 256-bit memory bus become the bottleneck, with even Low settings failing to reach 60 FPS.
Q: Is Ultra settings ever worth using with this hardware?
A: Only at 1080p, where 63.2 FPS remains playable. At 1440p, Ultra produces 37.2 FPS, and at 4K, 18.5 FPS, both of which are too low for comfortable gameplay.
Resolution Scaling
The performance drop from 1080p to 4K is dramatic and reveals the GPU as the primary constraint at higher resolutions. At Medium settings, the average FPS falls from 103.2 at 1080p to 67.7 at 1440p (a 35.5 FPS loss) and then to 35 at 4K (a 32.7 FPS loss from 1440p). This consistent degradation pattern indicates that the GTX 1070's 256.3 GB/s memory bandwidth and 6.463 TFLOPS of FP32 compute are insufficient for 4K rendering in this title.
The scaling from 1440p to 4K is proportionally more severe than from 1080p to 1440p. At High settings, the drop is 48.3 to 28 FPS (a 42% reduction), while the 1080p to 1440p drop is 81.1 to 48.3 FPS (a 40% reduction). This suggests that at 4K, the GPU is fully saturated, with the 1920 shading units and 64 ROPs unable to maintain the fill rate required.
At 1080p, the CPU's role becomes apparent. The difference between Low (127.1 FPS) and Ultra (63.2 FPS) spans 63.9 FPS, showing that the six-core i5-9400 with its 2.90 GHz base and 4.10 GHz boost clock can feed the GPU efficiently at lower resolutions. The 1080p Low result of 127.1 FPS is the highest measured value across all configurations, confirming that the CPU has headroom that the GPU cannot exploit at higher resolutions.
How This Combo Ranks
This specific combination of Intel Core i5-9400 and NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1070 ranks 1438 out of 1699 tested combos for Hard West, placing it in the bottom 15% of all configurations. This low ranking reflects the game's age and the hardware's mid-range positioning rather than any specific incompatibility. The combo's percentile standing is consistent with the CPU's 50th percentile and GPU's 51st percentile among all parts, suggesting that the pairing is well-balanced but unremarkable.
The ranking implies that most other tested combinations achieve higher frame rates, likely because turn-based tactics games are not demanding enough to require high-end hardware. The i5-9400's 6 cores and 6 threads, combined with the GTX 1070's 8 GB GDDR5 memory, place this combo in a performance tier where 1080p Medium is the ceiling for consistently smooth gameplay. The 1699-combo pool includes both older and newer hardware, and this pairing's position indicates it is better suited for 1080p gaming than for the higher resolutions where it struggles.
CPU Role
The Intel Core i5-9400 provides six physical cores with six threads, a 2.90 GHz base clock, and a 4.10 GHz boost clock. Its 9 MB of shared L3 cache and dual-channel DDR4 memory support contribute to a Cinebench R23 multicore score of 7969 and a single-core score of 1125. These synthetic results place the CPU in the 50th percentile, indicating average performance relative to all tested processors.
In Hard West, the CPU's role is most evident at 1080p where frame rates scale significantly with settings. The 127.1 FPS Low result demonstrates that the CPU can drive high frame rates when the GPU is not heavily loaded. The 63.9 FPS difference between Low and Ultra at 1080p suggests that while the GPU handles the increased visual load, the CPU maintains sufficient frame delivery across all settings. At 1440p and 4K, the CPU becomes less relevant as the GPU becomes the bottleneck, evidenced by the smaller percentage differences between settings at those resolutions.
The i5-9400's 65 W TDP and Coffee Lake architecture provide adequate single-thread performance for a turn-based tactics title, where the game logic and AI calculations likely run on a limited number of threads. The benchmark results show this CPU performs nearly identically to the Core i3-10305 (0.2% faster) and Core i3-1125G4 (0.2% faster), making it a mid-pack performer that does not bottleneck the GTX 1070 at 1080p.
Measured FPS Breakdown
At 1920x1080, the full settings range is playable. Low delivers 127.1 FPS, Medium 103.2 FPS, High 81.1 FPS, and Ultra 63.2 FPS. The 20 FPS steps between Low and Medium and between Medium and High provide predictable scaling, while the jump from High to Ultra costs 17.9 FPS.
At 2560x1440, performance drops significantly. Low produces 80.5 FPS, Medium 67.7 FPS, High 48.3 FPS, and Ultra 37.2 FPS. The Medium result remains above 60 FPS, making it the only setting at this resolution that achieves smooth gameplay. High and Ultra fall below the 60 FPS threshold, while Low sacrifices too much visual quality for its 80.5 FPS result.
At 3840x2160, all settings fall below playable thresholds. Low achieves 45.7 FPS, Medium 35 FPS, High 28 FPS, and Ultra 18.5 FPS. The 27.2 FPS difference between Low and Ultra at 4K is proportionally smaller than at other resolutions, confirming the GPU is the limiting factor. The GTX 1070's VRAM capacity of 8 GB is not the constraint here, as the game's 2015 release date suggests modest texture requirements; rather, the 107.7 GPixel/s pixel rate and 202.0 GTexel/s texture rate are insufficient for 4K rendering.
GPU Role
The NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1070 features 8 GB of GDDR5 memory on a 256-bit bus, providing 256.3 GB/s of bandwidth. Its GP104 chip contains 1920 shading units, 120 TMUs, and 64 ROPs, operating at a base clock of 1506 MHz and boost clock of 1683 MHz. The 6.463 TFLOPS of FP32 compute and 107.7 GPixel/s fill rate place it in the 51st percentile of all GPUs, with a Passmark G3D score of 13498.
In Hard West, the GPU's role becomes dominant at higher resolutions. The 4K results, where even Low settings fail to reach 60 FPS, directly reflect the GTX 1070's compute and memory bandwidth limits. The 256-bit memory interface, while adequate for 1080p and 1440p, cannot sustain the bandwidth required for 4K frame buffers. The 8 GB VRAM is sufficient for this game's textures, but the 150 W TDP and Pascal architecture's efficiency cannot compensate for the raw pixel throughput demands of 4K.
Comparing to its nearest rivals, the GTX 1070 is 0.7% faster than the Quadro K4200 (12241) and 1.4% slower than the GTX 1650 SUPER (12504). Its average benchmark score of 12331 versus the GTX 880M's 12490 shows a 1.3% deficit to that mobile chip. These narrow margins in synthetic benchmarks translate to the measured FPS results, where the GPU performs adequately at 1080p but falls short at 4K. The GTX 1070's 16 nm process and 7,200 million transistors on a 314 mm² die represent mid-range Pascal performance that is well-matched to the i5-9400 for 1080p gaming in this title.
Hardware Specifications
Intel Core i5-9400
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1070
FPS Benchmarks by Resolution & Settings
Performance data for Intel Core i5-9400 + NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1070 in Hard West
| Resolution | Settings | Avg FPS |
|---|---|---|
| 3840x2160 | Low | 45.7 |
| 3840x2160 | Medium | 35.0 |
| 3840x2160 | High | 28.0 |
| 3840x2160 | Ultra | 18.5 |
| 2560x1440 | Low | 80.5 |
| 2560x1440 | Medium | 67.7 |
| 2560x1440 | High | 48.3 |
| 2560x1440 | Ultra | 37.2 |
| 1920x1080 | Low | 127.1 |
| 1920x1080 | Medium | 103.2 |
| 1920x1080 | High | 81.1 |
| 1920x1080 | Ultra | 63.2 |
Other Games with ii5-9400 + GTX 1070
Explore FPS benchmarks for other games using this same hardware combination.