Instant compatibility check with FPS benchmarks and optimization tips
Thief
Performance
1080p (Full HD)
1440p (2K / QHD)
4K (Ultra HD)
Requirements Check
Recommendations
Your hardware doesn't meet minimum requirements for this game.
Your GPU supports ray tracing.
Average FPS: resolution vs quality settings
| Ultra | High | Medium | Low | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4K Ultra HD | 71 | 72 | 79 | 88 |
| 1440p QHD | 84 | 86 | 95 | 105 |
| 1080p Full HD | 96 | 97 | 107 | 119 |
Cell color: green is 120+ FPS, teal is 60+, amber is 30+, red is below 30. Cards marked Estimated above have no measured row and are scaled from your GPU benchmark percentile.
Performance Analysis: Thief on Your System
The Intel Core i5-9400 and NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4080 SUPER combination delivers a thoroughly playable experience in Thief across every resolution and preset tested. The data shows a system that is never constrained by the game's demands at 1080p or 1440p, and it even manages to hold a comfortable frame rate at 4K with maximum settings. The pairing of a mid-range six-core processor from 2018 with a flagship-class GPU from 2024 results in a GPU-bound system at higher resolutions, which is where the RTX 4080 SUPER can stretch its legs and deliver the majority of the performance.
Measured FPS Breakdown
At 1920x1080, the recorded frame rates are high across all four quality presets. The Low preset produces an average of 119 FPS, which is the highest figure recorded for this combination at any resolution. The Medium preset averages 107 FPS, with a minimum of 91 FPS and a maximum of 124 FPS, showing a tight and consistent frame delivery. The High preset averages 97 FPS, while the Ultra preset, the most demanding option, still manages an average of 96 FPS. The spread between Low and Ultra at 1080p is 23 FPS, which indicates that the CPU and GPU pair have enough headroom to absorb the extra load of higher graphical fidelity without a dramatic drop in performance.
Moving to 2560x1440, the average frame rates step down slightly but remain well above the playable threshold. The Low preset averages 105 FPS, a 14 FPS reduction from the 1080p result. The Medium preset averages 95 FPS, with a minimum of 81 FPS and a maximum of 109 FPS. The High preset averages 86 FPS, and the Ultra preset averages 84 FPS. The gap between the lowest and highest presets at 1440p is 21 FPS, which is nearly identical to the 1080p spread. This consistency suggests that the scaling between presets is stable, and the system is not encountering a sudden bottleneck as settings increase.
At 3840x2160, the performance remains respectable, though the impact of the higher pixel count is clear. The Low preset averages 88 FPS, the Medium preset averages 79 FPS with a minimum of 67 FPS and a maximum of 91 FPS, the High preset averages 72 FPS, and the Ultra preset averages 71 FPS. The difference between Low and Ultra at 4K is 17 FPS, which is a smaller relative drop than at lower resolutions. The minimum recorded frame rate of 67 FPS at 4K Medium is still above the 60 FPS playable threshold, indicating that even the most demanding scenario in the data does not dip below playable levels.
Best Settings per Resolution
The database indicates that the Ultra preset is the best setting at every resolution, as it is the most demanding option that still maintains an average above 60 FPS. At 1920x1080, the Ultra preset delivers an average of 96 FPS. At 2560x1440, the Ultra preset delivers an average of 84 FPS. At 3840x2160, the Ultra preset delivers an average of 71 FPS. In all three cases, the Ultra preset is the highest quality option available in the settings list, and it stays comfortably above the playable threshold. The data does not show any benefit to dropping to a lower preset for the sake of frame rate, since even the most demanding settings produce a smooth result.
CPU and GPU Roles
The performance scaling between resolutions reveals how the workload shifts between the Intel Core i5-9400 and the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4080 SUPER. At 1080p, the system is likely more dependent on the CPU, as the GPU has ample capacity to render frames quickly. The difference between Low and Ultra at 1080p is 23 FPS, and the average frame rates range from 96 to 119 FPS. When moving to 1440p, the average frame rates drop by roughly 11 to 14 FPS across presets, which is a moderate decline that indicates the GPU is beginning to take on more of the rendering load. The spread between Low and Ultra at 1440p is 21 FPS, nearly the same as at 1080p, which suggests the CPU is still keeping up with the GPU's output.
At 4K, the GPU becomes the dominant factor. The average frame rates drop further, with the Low preset at 88 FPS and the Ultra preset at 71 FPS. The spread between Low and Ultra narrows to 17 FPS, which is a sign that the GPU is now the limiting component. The CPU, which has a benchmark percentile of 47 among all CPUs, is less likely to hold back the system at this resolution because the GPU is spending more time on pixel processing. The RTX 4080 SUPER, which sits in the 86th percentile among all GPUs, has enough raw power to push high frame rates even at 4K, but the scaling shows that the GPU is the primary driver of performance differences across resolutions. The i5-9400's six cores and six threads are sufficient to feed the GPU at 1080p and 1440p, but the data suggests that the GPU is the component that determines the final frame rate at 4K.
FAQ
Q: Can this PC run Thief at 4K with maximum settings?
A: Yes. The Ultra preset at 3840x2160 averages 71 FPS, which is above the 60 FPS playable threshold.
Q: What is the best settings preset for 1440p?
A: The Ultra preset is the best choice at 2560x1440, delivering an average of 84 FPS while remaining the most demanding settings option.
Q: How much performance is lost when moving from 1080p to 1440p on the Ultra preset?
A: The Ultra preset drops from 96 FPS at 1920x1080 to 84 FPS at 2560x1440, a reduction of 12 FPS.
Q: Does the frame rate ever drop below 60 FPS in the measured data?
A: No. The lowest recorded minimum is 67 FPS, which occurs at 3840x2160 with the Medium preset.
Q: Which component has a greater impact on performance at 4K?
A: The data indicates the GPU is the dominant factor at 3840x2160, as the frame rate drop between Low and Ultra narrows to 17 FPS, suggesting the rendering load is on the graphics card.
Q: Is the Low preset ever necessary to achieve a playable frame rate?
A: No. The Low preset is not required at any resolution, as even the Ultra preset stays above 60 FPS at all tested resolutions.
Similar Performance Alternatives
The nearest rivals for the Intel Core i5-9400 show that its processing power is comparable to several other CPUs in the database. The Intel Core i7-1068NG7 is 0.2% behind in average benchmark score, making it effectively a performance match. The Intel Core i7-10710U is 0.3% ahead, while the AMD Ryzen 5 PRO 1500 is 0.4% ahead. The Intel Core i3-10305 is 0.4% behind. These small deltas mean that swapping the i5-9400 for any of these processors would likely produce nearly identical frame rates in Thief, assuming the GPU remains the same.
For the NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4080 SUPER, the nearest rivals are all within a few percentage points of its average benchmark score. The NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4080 is 0.1% behind, which makes it a nearly identical alternative. The AMD Radeon Pro W5700X is 1.1% behind, the AMD Radeon RX 6750 GRE 12 GB is 2.7% behind, and the AMD Radeon 8060S is 2.8% behind. A system built with any of these GPUs alongside the i5-9400 would deliver very similar performance in Thief, with the RTX 4080 being the closest match. The frame rates recorded for this combination would likely hold within a small margin if the GPU were swapped for one of these alternatives, since the differences in raw GPU score are minimal.
The Verdict
The recorded data shows that this PC can run Thief with no issues at any resolution or preset. At 1920x1080, the Ultra preset averages 96 FPS, and the Low preset reaches 119 FPS, so all settings clear the 60 FPS threshold. At 2560x1440, the Ultra preset averages 84 FPS, and the lowest recorded average is 84 FPS, which is still well above playable. At 3840x2160, the Ultra preset averages 71 FPS, and the Medium preset shows a minimum of 67 FPS, confirming that even the most demanding scenarios stay above 60 FPS. The verdict by resolution lists all four presets as playable at each resolution, with Ultra being the best setting at every level. This combination of a mid-range CPU and a high-end GPU is more than sufficient for Thief, and users can confidently enable the highest quality settings without sacrificing frame rate.